He met George Gershwin as a child and fell in love with his music. He went on to sell luxury goods by mail order like no one else — and then created one of the ultimate luxury goods: his very own George Gershwin musical on Broadway.
Roger Horchow, the Dallasite who created The Horchow Collection catalog and produced the now-classic Broadway musical, “Crazy for You,” died Saturday morning in his Dallas home with his three daughters. It came after a short battle with cancer, his daughter Sally Horchow confirmed. He was 91. Sally said there would be no memorial service.
“Dad wanted to be at his own memorial,” she said, “and since he can’t, we thought we’d honor his wishes.”
In addition to his successes in retail and on Broadway, Horchow was a significant benefactor to North Texas non-profits — including the Dallas Museum of Art, UTSouthwestern and KERA, where he served on the board for many years.
[The radio version has now been embedded above. Just click on the white arrow. It’s worth it.]
A retail pioneer
Horchow was the first retailer to sell high-end goods by mail-order catalog — without first opening a bricks-and-mortar store on the street to establish its reputation with buyers. He was so successful, he sold his mail-order outfit to the store that had hired him and inspired him: Neiman Marcus. Then he went on to win a Tony Award producing his very first show, which became a world-wide success. And this was when only one out of every 22 Broadway shows ever made its money back.
But perhaps Horchow’s real skill was not in knowing which sumptuous trinkets the affluent might buy. Or even in bringing back splashy American showbiz: He was profiled in a major bestselling book by Malcolm Gladwell for the simple reason that — as most people who met Horchow realized — he had a low-key friendliness, a charming, sleepy-eyed knack for getting to know just about everyone — and remembering them.
Samuel Roger Horchow’s father was a lawyer and a state government official. Even so, the younger Horchow was born into the retail business in Cincinnati in 1928. His Ohio family were mostly shopkeepers. His grandfather had been a pack peddler in the Austro-Hungarian Empire and eventually owned a general store in Crooksville, Ohio. Some of the largest stores in nearby Zanesville were owned by Horchow relatives, and Horchow later recalled being fascinated by Sears, Roebuck and the other mail-order catalogs of the day. They’d arrive in the post like Christmas packages to be unwrapped and pored over. He learned the personal art of sales by peddling Burpee’s flower seeds and magazine subscriptions door-to-door.
But it was while Horchow was on a summer break from majoring in sociology at Yale University that he truly found his calling: He went to work for the Lazarus family in Columbus, Ohio. They ran a department store that eventually became Federated Department Stores, owners of Foley’s, Sanger-Harris and Macy’s. Horchow started there by ironing curtains in the basement. He eventually became Foley’s top buyer of china and glassware.
Horchow served in the Korean War in security data analysis in Massachusetts and met his wife Carolyn Pfeifer — perhaps inevitably — in the fashion department at Bloomingdale’s in New York. The couple eventually had three daughters: Sally Horchow, Regen Horchow Fearon and Elizabeth Horchow Routman. In 1960, when he was offered a job in charge of the gift galleries at Neiman Marcus, the Horchows moved to Dallas. Roger soon became the vice-president at Neiman’s — the v.p. in charge of mail-order and catalog sales.
“He actually joined my father on a trip to Asia,” recalled Richard Marcus, son of Stanley Marcus and the former CEO of Neiman’s. “My dad had gone into China with my mother a couple years earlier. And I think the world suddenly got bigger for him [Horchow]. There was a sourcing opportunity for him, and he wanted to run his own show. And he did a good job of it.”
One source of Horchow’s impatience, says Marcus, is that Neiman’s was primarily known for its fashions — “soft goods,” in tradespeak — and Horchow saw how more could be done with home decor or “hard goods.” In 1971, after he learned he wouldn’t become head of the mail-order department quickly enough to suit him (and Neiman’s wouldn’t make their mail order business independent from the parent store), Horchow went to work for the Kenton Corporation, a conglomerate that owned some of America’s leading designer labels, including Cartier and Valentino. He started their catalog, the Kenton Collection, in May 1971.
What made no sense to successful retailers at the time was Horchow’s insistence that the choice of mail-order items should include products outside the stores’ day-to-day inventory and be handled not by the store’s usual buyers. They didn’t see mail order as a potentially independent (and therefore different) market but as just another (limited) revenue opportunity for what they already peddled.
Timing is everything
Indeed, Horchow’s new Kenton Collection lost one million dollars its first year in business — as Horchow had predicted. Then it lost another million in its second year. Which Horchow hadn’t predicted.
Still, Horchow was certain it would turn a profit in its third year. But the debt-ridden Kenton Corporation was bought by Rapid-American Corporation. So Horchow took the first big financial gamble in his life. He put together one million dollars — “hocking everything I could lay my hands on,” he said, borrowing from friends and family members and getting a $600,000 loan from a bank. On June 13, 1973, after signing nearly three hours’ worth of documents, he bought what Rapid-American was perfectly happy to sell him: his freedom to do what he wanted with his money-losing catalog.
In 1973 — as he would later recount in his 1980 mail-order memoir, “Elephants in Your Mailbox” (co-written with A. C. Greene) — Horchow would start the first luxury mail-order catalog that did not originate with a real, live retail outlet. The first issue received only 7,000 orders –but they were from people like Princess Grace. Horchow’s insight was that his catalog would offer both convenience and exclusivity. With the Sears catalog, you got what you could buy at any Sears. With the Horchow Collection, people couldn’t buy the fancy-schmancy items on their own — not unless they were willing to travel to meet Peruvian merchants or haggle in Irish villages known for their wool weaving. Customers of the exclusive Horchow Collection soon included Barbra Streisand, Frank Sinatra and Happy Rockefeller.
Before internet commerce came along and decimated a lot of mail order, Horchow’s success inspired all the freestanding, fashion-and-home-decor catalogs that soon followed: Frontgate, Levenger, Brookstone, Scully & Scully, Ballard Designs, Wisteria, Grandin Road. Horchow even created spin-offs of The Horchow Collection itself, and the whole business was so successful, he sold it all in 1988 to Neiman Marcus, just when The Horchow Collection was becoming increasingly indistinguishable from its many competitors.
Six years later, the first internet sales began. By then, Horchow was a major Broadway player.
In showbiz, as in investments, timing is everything.
Full circle with Gershwin
Horchow often recalled how, as a child, he was awakened one Sunday morning at his parent’s home by the sound of enticing piano music. In his pajamas, the six-year-old went downstairs to find George Gershwin playing the family piano. Horchow’s mother was a pianist, and the great composer was in Cincinnati for a concert. She learned he had some hours to kill before catching his train, so she invited him home. Hence, the impromptu morning performance. Roger Horchow eventually kept the piano in his own home for decades and although he never learned to read music, he would play Gershwin and other Broadway standards on it by ear. (The piano is reportedly bequeathed to his youngest daughter, Sally.)
By the 1980s, Horchow was already investing in Broadway shows, but in 1992, he set out to fulfill a stagestruck dream. He wanted to see a full-scale, glittery, George-and-Ira Gershwin musical — but done fresh. With permission from the Gershwin estate, he snagged several iconic tunes — like “Someone to Watch Over Me” — from other Gershwin musicals, and he hired playwright Ken Ludwig and director Mike Ockrent to update and refashion the Gershwin brothers’ original 1930 show, “Girl Crazy,” whose storyline and jokes had become dated.
The project became “Crazy for You” and with it, Horchow brought old-style, commercial American showbiz — complete with sequined chorus dancers, splashy sets and romantic leads singing infectious tunes — back to Broadway. It was shamelessly entertaining. At the time, the New York stage was dominated by somber, wannabe operas generally imported from England or France — heavyweight spectacles such as “Miss Saigon” and “Phantom of the Opera.”
“Crazy for You” opened like a magnum of vintage champagne. “The New York Times” review called the show the re-birth of Broadway. It ran for four years and grossed more than $92 million. It may well have started the entire ’90s genre of “revisals” – heavily re-worked classic Broadway shows such as “Chicago,” “Cabaret” and “The Most Happy Fella.” Thanks to director Ockrent and choreographer Susan Stroman, Horchow’s own vision of ten chorus dancers happily popping out of a limousine one by one — like tap-dancing clowns from a pricey clown car — that vision was realized with “I Can’t Be Bothered Now,” one of the show’s show-stopping numbers. It was featured on the Tony Awards TV presentation in 1992 (above).
That was the awards show where Horchow picked up his first Tony as a producer. It also launched Stroman’s career as a leading choreographer-director.
In 1993, after bringing “Crazy for You” to Dallas to open its national tour, Horchow declared he wasn’t interested in creating another Broadway show. He was quitting while he was on top. In the following years, he oversaw other productions of “Crazy for You” (including one in Japan). But he was too old, he said, to start another show from scratch — he was 64 at the time. So Horchow planned on peacefully ignoring all the pitches for new theater projects that were piling up on his desk. He had wanted his dreamed-of Gershwin musical and he’d gotten his dreamed-of Gershwin musical.
In 1995, he even got to perform in his dreamed-of Gershwin musical. Horchow stepped in for a week of “Crazy for You” shows, playing the father of the female lead, Jodi Benson. Sally Horchow asked her father how he felt. “I am so tired,” she reports him saying. “My feet hurt. I had to put them up between matinees and evening performances.”
It gave him, she says, a new appreciation for what professional actors do on a daily basis.
Horchow eventually donated his Gershwin memorabilia and records and files from ‘Crazy for You’ to the Harry Ransom Center at UT-Austin
But over the next 24 years, Horchow proceeded to produce or co-produce six more Broadway shows, winning a second Tony Award in 2000, this time for best revival of a musical with Cole Porter’s “Kiss Me Kate.” The 2008 revival of “Gypsy” — for which he was a co-producer — earned him only a best revival nomination. But it starred Patti Lupone — and she won her second Tony Award in it, her first since “Evita,” 28 years before (below).
In 2009, Horchow’s wife Carolyn died after a long struggle with cancer. They had been married for 49 years.
“They were both quiet,” says Kern Wildenthal, president emeritus of UTSouthwestern. “They complemented each other. But she never missed a beat. Anything going on, she knew what was happening.”
Friends commented that afterwards, Roger seemed a little lost without her — and without a project to keep him focused. Her sense of style had been one of the inspirations for the Horchow Collection, and she’d traveled most places with him. When “Crazy for You” was enduring its nail-biting tryout in Washington, D.C, Carolyn could be found in the theater, seated next to Roger, calmly doing needlepoint and quietly giving him smart advice.
Like her husband, Carolyn had been extensively involved in North Texas non-profits and charities, including Meals on Wheels and UTSouthwestern. Both of the Horchows received medical care there, and Carolyn helped organize a women’s health care symposium at the Medical Center. Roger eventually donated money to have the annual, day-long event named the Carolyn P. Horchow Women’s Health Symposium. According to Wildenthal, Roger took delight in attending it.
While Roger may have been out of the creating-new-shows-from-classics business, he continued investing in other people’s musicals — including “Hamilton” and “The Book of Mormon.” But in 2018 — having produced “Bandstand” on Broadway — he announced he was investing in a revival of “Crazy for You” — with its original choreographer, Susan Stroman, now slated to direct.
All they needed, he said, was the right Broadway theater available for a good length of time.
But unlike that first time, it’s two years later since his announcement, and they still haven’t gotten one. During recent seasons, an open Broadway stage has become an extremely rare commodity — when tourist blockbusters like “The Lion King,” “Phantom of the Opera” and “Wicked” continue to sit there, decade after decade.
The Horchow Connection
Not surprisingly — for someone who’d been a successful author, mail-order merchant, Broadway investor, producer and philanthropist — Horchow had a knack for making friends. It was a skill that author Malcolm Gladwell highlighted in a feature story in “The New Yorker” in 1999. Gladwell, the author of such later bestsellers as “Blink” and “Outliers,” wrote about the kind of people who seem to know everyone — or if not, they always know someone else who knows the person in question.
Horchow was a prime practitioner of friendly networking. Gladwell met Horchow through Horchow’s daughter Lizzie, who went to a school with a friend of the Canadian journalist. At the time of “The New Yorker” story — pre-Facebook, pre-Snapchat, pre-Twitter and pre-WhatsApp — Gladwell reported that Horchow had a computerized Rolodex with contact information on sixteen hundred people.
Gladwell wrote: “I kept asking him how all the connections in his life had helped him in the business world, because I thought that this particular skill had to have been cultivated for a reason. But the question seemed to puzzle him. He didn’t think of his people collection as a business strategy, or even as something deliberate. He just thought of it as something he did — as who he was.”
Horchow had what Gladwell dubbed “the Horchow Connection.” But as long ago as his 1980 memoir, “Elephants in Your Mailbox,” Horchow himself bragged about his ability to know someone, anyone, an old friend, a business associate — in just about any corner on Earth. During his first buying trip to China in the early ’70s — well before America was even really trading with the People’s Republic — Horchow stayed in a Peking hotel full of nothing but Chinese sellers. There were a tiny number of Western buyers, most of them European. Horchow went up to one of the only Americans in all of Peking and said, “You’re Jonathan Sloat and we were in the class of 1950 at Yale.”
“Of course,” Sloat replied. “You’re Roger Horchow.”
In 2000, “The New Yorker” profile of Horchow was featured in Gladwell’s first book of pop sociology, the bestseller that made the author famous: “The Tipping Point: How Little Things Can Make A Big Difference.” In 2006, Horchow and his daughter Sally turned Roger’s approach to friendliness into an advice book, “The Art of Friendship: 70 Simple Rules For Making Meaningful Connections.” It was his third book, after “Elephants in Your Mailbox” and “Living In Style: In a Time When Taste Means More Than Money” from 1981.
Horchow always spoke in a slow, gentle drawl — it suited his sleepy eyes and dry sensibility. But that speaking style did not make his audiobook recordings particularly gripping. They didn’t convey his warmth or dry humor.
Excerpt from the introduction to Horchow’s audiobook version of “The Art of Friendship”:
But in the early 1990s, Horchow found his speaking style could be a shrewd negotiating tool. He was struggling to put together “Crazy for You,” and for the first time, he was wrangling with big-name Broadway designers over a ballooning budget. Investors in a show generally aren’t the ones to do this. It’s what producers do: They bring the artistic team together and hammer out what’s going to get spent. Then they get investors to bankroll the whole package.
But “Crazy for You” didn’t have to wait years to rustle up backers and raise money. Broadway veteran Elizabeth Williams was officially co-producer of the show, but she was really there to advise Horchow, whose whole idea the show was but who was also writing the checks. So the typically tedious investment process barely existed. They already had all the money they needed. They just needed a theater and a date.
And then the Shubert Theater suddenly became available.
Everything that Horchow’s team had decided they wanted had to be purchased, rented or arranged now-now-now — winches, wigs, scenery, lighting, transportation, size of orchestra — all of it in advance of the Washington, D.C,. tryout in January 1992. The New York premiere was only a month later.
With such a sudden time crunch, costs went through the roof.
But eventually, Horchow said, he learned to use his sleepy voice to his advantage. During intense arguments with designers and technicians over budgets, he said he would go over each line item carefully.
“And you know, I talk pretty slow as it is,” he said.
And he’d ask more questions and get even slower.
Then his eyes would glaze over.
Eventually, everyone gave up and the costs would start to come down.
Roger Horchow is survived by his three daughters, Sally Horchow, Regen Horchow Fearon and Elizabeth Horchow Routman; his son-in-law Daniel Routman; granddaughters Samantha Pillsbury, Regen and Emily Routman, Fiona and Sabrina Fearon; brother-in-law Eugene M. Pfeifer III and Linda Pfeifer of Little Rock, Arkansas.
RESPONSES TO THE DEATH OF ROGER HORCHOW:
STATEMENT BY PRESIDENT GEORGE W. BUSH ON ROGER HORCHOW
CRAWFORD, TEXAS — “Dallas lost a wonderful man today with the passing of Roger Horchow. Roger was a person of culture, humor, and generosity. He was important to Laura and me—and to so many fortunate friends. We send our heartfelt condolences to Roger’s daughters and grandchildren.”
From Nico Leone, president and CEO of KERA.
He sent the following message to the board of KERA. Horchow was a long-time supporter of the station and had served on its board:
“Roger was a dedicated and longstanding member of our Board, most recently confirmed as an Honorary Life Director. He also was a titan in the North Texas philanthropic community who made significant investments in local institutions, including KERA, Dallas Museum of Art, UT Southwestern and many more.
“Beyond his successful career as an entrepreneur, Roger was also an award-winning Broadway producer. When he recorded a video testimonial for KERA’s major gifts program, he treated the crew to a piano performance – his Tony Award proudly displayed above the keys. It was just one of the moments with Roger that our KERA family will never forget.
“Roger’s commitment to KERA extended throughout the Horchow family. His son-in-law, Dan Routman, is a former KERA Board Chair who served alongside Roger and continues to serve as an Honorary Life Director.
On behalf of the KERA family, our thoughts are with Dan and Roger’s entire family, including his three daughters.”
From Agustín Arteaga, The Eugene McDermott Director of the Dallas Museum of Art:
“Roger was incredibly passionate, generous, and community-minded. His theatrical charm and giving personality have inspired all of us at the DMA for decades and certainly me since I joined the Museum. While his support for our building, special exhibitions, the collections, and public programming were immense, he never lost his passion for retail, and he constantly found ways to use it in service to the Museum. Whenever Roger said he was coming by, I knew the first place I would find him was in the DMA Store, fiddling with everything from the window dressing to the white lights, and making sure visitors could find something to buy. His leadership and support of the DMA has played an important role in making our Museum the dynamic place it is today. I am thankful I had the opportunity to know Roger and his family. We will miss his wink, his sly humor, his critical thinking, and his smile. We will mourn him. Our condolences go out to his daughters Regen, Lizzie and Sally and their families.”
From Nancy Cain Marcus, Southern Methodist University professor:
Mail merchant prince turned successful Broadway producer, Roger Horchow was whip-smart and witty to the end. Unsparing when confronting platitudes, Roger was both an attentive if no-nonsense friend and an entertaining one to many around the world.
To receive an invitation to one of his dinner parties, whether in Dallas, New York or Nantucket, was to anticipate a good time because Roger always had a way of rounding up an interesting mix with a surprising guest or two at his tables, every one often ending in song. An elegant gentleman with ready one-liners to amuse and provoke, Roger was a stickler for tradition, sending hand-written notes in handsome script to his countless correspondents. Roger may have had the best fun when he was producing musical theater, which revealed him to be no more worldly-wise than a sophisticated romantic.
In the end, Roger was best known to those close to him as a devoted family man. In the storied success of his own life, Roger’s only leading lady was Carolyn Horchow, his wife of 49 years. His devotion extended to their daughters, Regen, Lizzie and Sally, his son-in-law Dan and offspring of the next generation, all of whom together comprise the proudest cast of Roger Horchow’s masterpiece production.
Got a tip? Email Jerome Weeks at [email protected] You can follow him on Twitter @dazeandweex.
Art&Seek is made possible through the generosity of our members. If you find this reporting valuable, consider making a tax-deductible gift today. Thank you.