I'm looking for...

That is

Guest Review: James Magee at the Nasher
by Patricia Mora 1 Oct 2010

Guest blogger Patricia Mora finds the work of James Magee majestic and difficult. Read her review, and others’ reactions to Magee’s show at the Nasher Sculpture Center.


Guest blogger Patricia Mora is a writer living in Dallas. During her career, she’s written about art and architecture in a variety of media. She earned a Master’s degree in Humanities and has studied Comparative Religion under Harvard professor Diana Eck.

"For Miguel," by James Magee

The loveliest things with which we keep company, art included, burn with the burden of the unspeakable. They remain smudged mysteries, objective correlatives, that affect our psyches so profoundly that we’re rendered stunned and happy mutes. How wonderful, then, that The Nasher Collection’s Revelation: The Art of James Magee encompasses an array of sculpture so profound it carries enough pent-up sonic jolt to create a new world, whole and entire.

For forty years Magee has worked quietly, attracting only the attention of a handful of scholars and devotees. His work is clearly an amalgam of the sacred and the profane — but rarely has an artist made it more apparent that both spheres share space and are inextricably woven. They don’t reside independently; rather, what one could call artistic “transubstantiation” is Magee’s perpetual work in progress. His career has spanned the gamut of cab driver, welder, legal advisor and inveterate survivor of the Hudson River Piers, a vast collection of abandoned warehouses that provided a place for men to explore their homosexual inclinations without the intrusion of daylight. These assorted vocations meld with a sensibility so delicate and profound that one feels they’re in the presence of what the Psalmists refer to as “the secret place of thunder.”

Paradise Overcast is a case in point. It’s a moody, weathered panel of rolled steel that’s scratched and over-worn. It’s a scarred island of redacted memory. The piece alone is an aching reminder of our lives and how they become etched with experience and memory. But when taken into context with the accompanying poetry of the artist’s “title,” one hears a chanting reminder that the gods reside in tangled bed sheets as readily as in tabernacles. It’s an unnerving mash-up of Sunday school and a foray into the gay underground of New York bars.

Another work by Magee, Untitled, demands that we limn the meaning of painting versus sculpture. It’s housed in a heavy, shallow box that holds all manner of glorious planetary stuff — steel, bright-red shells and god-knows-what-else. It’s palpable magic that engages us with an aria-like immediacy. It’s layered and textured in a way that intimates both bodily corpuscles and our “other” (ethereal) selves. It’s cell-by-cell raw nerves; it’s deep as a ravine; it’s a prayer so fierce it makes me shut my eyes lest I be burned by its light. And, ultimately, I suspect it operates as a painting might, rather than as a sculpture. It’s a juxtaposition of color and form and it ignites with the same dreamy, medium-hot flame one might associate with a Rauschenberg.

Conversely, Winter River throws us through the (metaphorical) windshield. The simplicity of the work is stunning. One can’t help but be shocked by the magic that’s conjured by a simple trinity of mundane materials: lead, steel and glass. It becomes a trope for falling through ice, descent and even drowning. It’s a beautiful fissure turned scarily sublime, a reminder that a lovely, greenish split can become the cosmic divide through which one might literally slip. Moreover, this eerie sensation is confirmed by the accompanying intonation of Magee’s poetic rendition of his own private saga of ancestors, one of whom is named “Jacob” no less.

For Miguel is haunting and lovely, a tiny cathedral for the wounded and wounding. It’s a ravaged surface of metal shavings, paprika, grease and glue, glass and steel. It’s also accompanied by a poem that’s sexy and raw — not to mention spatial in the way that Wallace Stevens’ poetry constellates volume and plenitude. Together, the montage of sound and sight topple your sensibility into the artist’s world of a “rented room” and a simple “yellow vase” that, again, is reminiscent of Stevens’ “jar in Tennessee.”

"Mine Shaft," by James Magee

This is art one is able to witness rarely in a lifetime. It’s a chance to enter a room where the proverbial white-hot light resides. However, if you’re expecting harps and clouds when you visit the Realm Sublime, you might discover that Paradise is firmly fixed in rusting metal, car parts and windshields. I found it all rather transcendent — then subsequently bumped my head on the bottom of the metaphorical pool when I heard the poetry that accompanies each piece. It was quite a trajectory. But when I recovered from my own preconceptions of what Magee’s art “should” be, I found my sensibilities had been fully educated and made to plumb both the heights and the (equally vital) depths.

This isn’t just a good show. It’s majestic and difficult. The Nasher’s Revelation is lovely and deeply so. It’s a clean, new notch on the belt for Dallas in terms of the “world-class” art scene. In Texas vernacular, maybe the city finally really does own both “hat and cattle.”

  • Beth Lazenby

    An insightful review by Patricia Mora. Looking forward to seeing the show.

  • Sydnie Kempen

    Excellent review. The depth of understanding and evocative language mirror the 3 dimensional nature of the exhibit.

  • Terri Thoman

    My meager words of praise would do no justice to these beautiful prose. Thanks, I’ll be sure to visit the Nasher.

  • Missy Finger

    It was indeed a powerful show. I was fortunate to hear him speak at the Nasher.
    Thanks Patricia for explaining why it was so powerful.

  • David Hughes

    This is by far the most intelligent review I’ve read in ages. This critic is insightful and far more articulate than anyone we might find outside The New York Times. Good gosh, where did this kind of talent come from? She does Magee justice and that’s more than I’ve seen elsewhere. Thank you KERA for featuring this kind of wonderful and challenging writing. And it’s local? This is great. Keep it coming!

  • Patricia Mora

    I am deeply appreciative of all your generous comments. Missy Finger and David Hughes, you guys are amazingly kind. And to some familiar names, I couldn’t be more pleased to have such great friends. Thanks for reading! This is such great, good fun.